Wednesday, July 20, 2011

Guest Post - Teen Book Review

Special treat: I get the day off because my son is here with a book review of Warlock by Michael Scott (The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel series). Enjoy!

Alcatraz:
Although their ally Dr. John Dee has been declared utlaga, Machiavelli and Billy the Kid will follow the plans the Elders have laid before them: they will loose the monsters of Alcatraz on the city of San Francisco, thereby triggering the end of the humani race.

Danu Talis:
The Shadowrealm that Scatty and Joan of Arc have entered is far more dangerous than they could ever have imagined. And they haven’t landed here by chance-the warriors were called for a reason. So were Saint-Germain, Palamededs, and Shakespeare. The group was summoned because they must travel back in time to Danu Talis and destroy it. For the island of Danu Talis, known in humani myth as the lost city of Atlantis, must fall if the modern world is to exist.


San Francisco:
The end is finally near.
Josh Newman has chosen a side, and he will not stand with his sister, Sophie, or with the Alchemyst, Nicholas Flamel. He will fight alongside Dee and the mysterious Virginia Dare. Unless Sophie can find her twin before the battle begins, all is lost – forever.

In the fifth installment of this bestselling series, the twins of prophesy have been divided, and the end is finally beginning.

With Scatty, Joan of Arc, Saint Germain, Palamedes, and Shakespeare all in Danu Talis, Sophie is on her own with the ever-weakening Nicholas and Perenelle Flamel. She must depend on Niten to help her find an immortal to teach her Earth Magic. The surprise is that she will find her teacher in the most ordinary of places. (dillonscott.com)

Review by Adam Abiad

Warlock  was very similar to the fourth book, Necromancer, but not anything like the first three in the series. Scott has to summarize for too many characters and it's several chapters before any interesting new action takes place. This also meant too many switches in perspective. You're reading about the Flamels and Sophie, and the next chapter is Dee, Dare, and Josh. Then some characters switch sides, and even worlds. There are also flashbacks to Danu Talis, just to add another switch. The switches make you lose interest. It gets intense at the end of each chapter and you want more, but you don't get it, and you have to remember the last time you read about the next character.

Scott crammed the action, added more cool new monsters, and increased the pace. Sophie's chapters are typically more talking than action. Josh's chapters are where all the excitment is. Supporting characters are just filling in blanks. There's no other way though. The other books kept adding characters and they all need to reach the goal. All that and there's still one more book. I hope Warlock took care of most of the loose ends.

7 comments:

Sarah said...

Very astute review, Adam! I have trouble with books that do so much perspective-switching like this, for the exact same reason you mention--I get to the end of a particular chapter and want more, which makes me race with frustration through subsequent chapters just to get back to the character I'm most interested in.

Old Kitty said...

What a fabulous review, thank you Adam! I'm not a fan of pov switches unless it's done seamlessly and I don't notice. But this book's redeeming qualities sound amazing - action-packed sequences and more monsters!

Thank you, take care x

Matthew MacNish said...

I've read the first three of these, and am kind of lukewarm about them. There are some awesome parts, but I basically agree with you here, Adam.

Thanks!

The Golden Eagle said...

Great review!

I read the first book in this series--I keep meaning to get around to the others!

Natalie said...

Adam, you did a GREAT job!

Samantha Vérant said...

Great review, Adam! I haven't read any of these, but I may try the first. We'll see...

Regina said...

I have this ARC but have yet to read it because I have not read the other four yet. I need to get around to them.

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails